logo
⌘K
Meditate Together Learn MBSR Online Retreats Facilitator Certification
Resources
About
Log In
mMeditate Together
lLearn MBSR
oOnline Retreats
fFacilitator Certification
rResources
oOMBSR
wWackfulness
eExercises & Practices
rResearch & Trends
sSummit Sessions
aAbout
sSummit
cContact
Log In
Back

Is Insight Timer One of the Good Guys?

Wackfulness
Mindful Leader·Nov 17, 2026· 9 minutes

By Mo Edjlali, Founder of Mindful Leader; Author, Open MBSR

Last week, one of our Meditate Together Group leads sent me a Reddit thread titled Tired and heart broken at the direction IT [Insight Timer] is taking. A few days later, another member of our community asked me, practically glowing, whether I'd seen Insight Timer CEO Christopher Plowman's talk at Transform Trauma Oxford.

The Reddit post described a meditation app starting to feel like social media. Plowman's speech tore into the attention economy and presented Insight Timer as something different.

Same company. Two very different stories. Interesting….

Before I go further, you should know where I'm standing. I created and run Meditate Together, a subscription-based meditation app and community. I also wrote Open MBSR - reimagining the future of mindfulness.  I have a clear vision for responsible and ethical approaches to teaching mindfulness meditation. In some ways, we compete with Insight Timer. And in some ways we wrestle with many of the same tensions. Regardless I have a bias  though will try to approach this as fairly as I possibly can. 

The Case for Applause

  1. It put meditation in millions of pockets.

Insight Timer says more than 30 million people use its platform. It offers an enormous library of meditations, music, and talks, much of it free. There are also courses, live sessions, and community groups. I remember when it was just a timer. Pick a bell, set the length, sit. No guru required. I loved it. And that timer is still there. Its paid subscriptions help fund this substantial free library. Whatever else we might think about the company, making meditation accessible to millions is a real contribution.

  1. It gave independent teachers a stage.

Most meditation teachers don't have a marketing department or a tech team. Insight Timer gives tens of thousands of teachers access to a global audience and opportunities to earn income from their work. Meditation teacher Lou Redmond, who has taught on the platform since 2016, credits Insight Timer with helping him build his career. In a March 2025 interview with Plowman, they discussed the company's changing compensation system. Plowman argued that the old system rewarded popularity too heavily. The new one, he said, could give lesser-known teachers a better chance to succeed by rewarding content that encourages people to practice regularly. He pointed to an 83-day course that had become one of the platform's biggest earners. The teacher invited students back for the next lesson, and the course received outstanding reviews. A teacher earning more because people are building a steady practice? I can get behind that.

  1. Its CEO is asking the right questions.

At Transform Trauma Oxford, Plowman went after social media, influencer culture, and algorithms designed to exploit our attention. His vision for Insight Timer is ambitious: human-created teachings, broad free access, and a Map of Healing connecting contemplative traditions with science. He's also been candid about how difficult it is to build a profitable company without selling out. I appreciate that. Anyone who has run a mission-driven organization knows good intentions don't pay the bills. And if a successful business can help people establish healthier meditation habits while supporting thousands of teachers, that's something worth celebrating. It's a strong case, and one I take seriously.

The Case for Raised Eyebrows

  1. It's paying teachers to bring you back.

In that same interview with Lou Redmond, Plowman explained: We needed people to come back to our platform more frequently. And so we introduced return rates. He said the idea came from Duolingo, where the company learned the importance of bringing existing users back. Nothing particularly sinister about that. Every business wants returning customers. But Insight Timer isn't selling language lessons or running shoes. It's providing meditation education and supporting relationships between teachers and students. That changes the ethical stakes.

According to Insight Timer's own compensation policy, 25% to 30% of the teacher-income pool is allocated to the Return Rate Bonus. Teachers can earn additional money when listeners return to Insight Timer the next day at above-average rates, even if they come back to use the timer or listen to another teacher.  But let's be clear, meditation teachers occupy a position of extraordinary trust. Their job is to help students grow. But what happens when the compensation system encourages them to bring students back to an app, even when those students might be better served becoming less dependent on it? Regular meditation is good. Financially sustainable teaching is good. But when the teacher's financial incentives and the student's long-term interests may diverge, we have an ethical problem worth confronting.

  1. It's starting to look like the thing it criticizes.

The Reddit writer had used Insight Timer for more than five years. The app had been a refuge from social media. Now the writer was seeing autoplaying videos, clickbait, and growing competition for attention.

One line captures the frustration:

The irony of a meditation app adopting the same attention-grabbing tactics we're trying to disconnect from is hard to ignore.

But a comment beneath Plowman's Oxford speech raised a remarkably similar concern.

The viewer, @Beyondthenoise-j1s, questioned Insight Timer's increasing emphasis on short-form videos, algorithms, celebrity teachers, and popularity over substance. The commenter also worried about longtime teachers earning less as the platform grew. The commenter put it this way:

Insight Timer has created something that has potential to do good, which is precisely why its increasing commercialisation feels so disappointing. It was once such a refreshing alternative to the commodification of wellbeing. I sincerely hope it doesn’t gradually become another expression of the very culture it seeks to challenge.

And he added:

Perhaps the most important question is this: are we helping people become more present, connected and less dependent on external stimulation, or are we simply finding more sophisticated ways to keep them engaged with an app?

That's a hell of a question to ask beneath a speech condemning the attention economy. In that same speech, Plowman warned that in today's attention economy, "Whoever has the most followers wins." His critics worry that Insight Timer is beginning to play that game itself. And there's an even deeper contradiction. The company criticizes algorithms optimized to capture attention while openly acknowledging that its own algorithms favor content that brings people back.

Now, returning to meditate is not the same as doomscrolling. Let's not pretend it is. But the last thing an app designed to help us understand our minds should do is manipulate our minds for the sake of profit and growth.

  1. Spirituality for sale.

Scroll through Insight Timer's marketplace and you'll find mindfulness alongside Reiki, chakra healing, manifestation, and all sorts of spiritual offerings. People should be free to explore whatever speaks to them. But let's not pretend these are all the same thing. A soothing visualization isn't mindfulness meditation. Belief in chakras isn't a scientific finding. And claims about energy healing don't become evidence-based simply because they're offered on a platform that talks enthusiastically about science.

I raised a related concern back in 2023 in Spirituality for Sale. What happens when spiritual authority and commercial interests become entangled? Who's looking out for the person seeking guidance? There's nothing inherently wrong with making a living teaching meditation. But when spiritual authority becomes a marketing tool and promises of transformation become products to sell, we should start asking uncomfortable questions.

Then there's the guru problem. Yes, the Return Rate Bonus may encourage students to explore different teachers rather than attach themselves to just one. But the larger marketplace still revolves around personalities, followers, and an endless supply of guided content. That creates opportunities for genuine teaching. It can also create opportunities for charismatic personalities selling transformation to people who may be vulnerable, searching for answers, or simply hoping someone can make their suffering go away.

Spiritual authority is powerful. Add money, celebrity, and promises of healing, and we'd better have some safeguards. I've argued in Please Shut Up: Your Guided Meditations Are Doing Harm that a good meditation teacher should eventually become less necessary. The student learns the practice. The teacher stops talking.

But what happens when the business depends on the teacher never shutting up?

So, Is Insight Timer One of the Good Guys?

I'm not sure there's a simple answer.

Insight Timer has done some real good. Many have benefited from its free resources, and thousands of teachers have gained opportunities that might never have existed otherwise.

But there are legitimate concerns about a business model that rewards platform engagement, a growing resemblance to social media, and a marketplace where evidence-based mindfulness sits alongside some pretty questionable metaphysical teachings.

None of this is unique to Insight Timer. Many organization in this field faces these tensions.

I want mindfulness to help people develop their own practice, question their teachers, and distinguish science from belief. I want secular mindfulness, no metaphysics, no stealth Buddhism, to bring people together across religious and nonreligious backgrounds without becoming a recruitment channel for someone else's spiritual worldview.

And I want organizations doing this work ethically and responsibly to be financially sustainable. The question I've been wrestling with while developing Open MBSR and building Meditate Together is one I think the entire field needs to confront:

What’s your vision for the future of mindfulness? What principles should guide us toward a more open, transparent, and responsible field?

I think every teacher, CEO, and leader in this field should be willing to answer those questions.

For now, I'll leave the verdict on Insight Timer to you.


Join the Conversation

Insight Timer users and teachers, I'd love to hear from you. What am I getting right? What am I missing?

Christopher Plowman and the Insight Timer team are welcome to respond. I'd be happy to publish their response in full.

Further Reading

Insight Timer and community responses

  • Tired and heart broken at the direction Insight Timer is taking (Reddit; title expanded for clarity)
  • Christopher Plowman's Oxford speech and viewer comments
  • Plowman's March 2025 interview with Lou Redmond
  • Losing 50% of My Insight Timer Income
  • Insight Timer: Understanding Return Rates
  • Insight Timer: Teacher Income FAQ

More from Mindful Leader

  • Please Shut Up: Your Guided Meditations Are Doing Harm
  • 4 Signs You're a Mindful Zombie
  • Spirituality for Sale


Older post Meditate Like a Bad Ass: Insights from Military Veterans

❤️ AA
Comments

Please log in or register to post a comment
About